Candy Corn Jello Cups

Candy Corn Jello Cups are my go to for Halloween celebrations when I want a dessert that is festive playful and guaranteed to brighten the dessert table. These fun layered treats look just like candy corn and come together with minimal effort making them perfect for parties and family gatherings. There is something about the combination of orange and yellow jello topped with a flurry of whipped cream and a single candy corn that never fails to make both kids and adults smile.

I have made these so many times with my kids and they are always eager to help with the layers and add the finishing candy corn touch. We now make it a tradition every October and the process is just as much fun as the eating.

Ingredients

• Lemon flavored jello: gives that sunny yellow layer and sweet tang plus it sets up beautifully for stacking
• Orange flavored jello: delivers that bright orange hue and citrus flavor and pairs perfectly with the lemon base
• Cold water: ensures the jello sets with the ideal texture and is important for cooling the mix quickly
• Boiling water: is necessary to properly dissolve the gelatin and bring out the colors
• Whipped cream or whipped topping: adds a creamy contrast and playful finish to each cup
• Candy corn: is the signature garnish that makes these instantly festive
• Clear plastic cups or mini dessert cups: allow the vibrant layers to show off and make serving a breeze

• When choosing store brand or name brand jello: always check for vibrant color and the freshest box so your layers set evenly

Step by Step Instructions

Prepare the Lemon Layer:

Boil one cup of water in a kettle or saucepan then pour it into a medium bowl and add the lemon jello powder. Stir slowly and continuously for about two minutes making sure every last bit is dissolved. Add half a cup of cold water then mix again gently. Divide the lemon mixture evenly among eight clear cups using a ladle or measuring cup. Place the cups on a tray for stability and refrigerate for at least one hour or until fully set. Be patient and do not rush the chilling or the layers will blend.

Prepare the Orange Layer:

Once the lemon layer is completely firm repeat the same process with the orange jello. Boil one cup of water dissolve in the orange jello mix and stir for a full two minutes paying attention to dissolve every grain. Add half a cup of cold water and stir gently. Carefully pour the orange jello mixture over the chilled lemon layer by using a spoon or pouring very slowly against the side of the cup to avoid disrupting the first layer. Chill again for another hour or until the jello is fully set.

Finish the Cups:

Once both layers are solid add a generous spoonful of whipped cream or your favorite whipped topping right on top of each jello cup. This creamy layer gives the cups that classic candy corn look and the flavors balance out the tartness below.

Add the Garnish:

Nestle a single candy corn or a small pile of candy corns right in the whipped cream of each cup. It is an instant way to make each treat look extra festive and irresistible.

Serve and Enjoy:

Keep the finished jello cups chilled until serving time. Arrange them on a tray and watch the kids eyes light up when you bring them out. These are best eaten cold and are just as delicious the next day.

Bookmark

The clear cups are my favorite part since you can see the perfect stripes every time. My youngest always insists on putting the candy corn on top herself and I treasure the giggles and sticky fingers from that moment every year.

Storage Tips

Candy Corn Jello Cups store best covered loosely in the refrigerator. Use plastic wrap or snap on lids to prevent them from drying out and keep them in a single layer so the whipped topping stays fluffy. They stay fresh for up to three days but for best results add the whipped cream and candy corn just before serving so the garnish stays perky.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you cannot find lemon or orange jello you can easily swap in pineapple or mango for yellow and peach or tangerine for orange. For a dairy free option choose plant based whipped toppings that hold shape well. And for a lower sugar version look for light or sugar free jello mixes.

Bookmark

Serving Suggestions

Set these cups out on a large tray surrounded by mini pumpkins and Halloween themed napkins for an eye catching dessert display. They also make adorable favors for classroom parties. For an extra indulgence sprinkle a tiny bit of crushed vanilla cookies between the layers for added texture.

Cultural Context

The inspiration for Candy Corn Jello Cups comes from classic American Halloween candies and the longstanding love affair with themed treats. Candy corn has been part of fall traditions for over a century and this dessert playfully celebrates that with each colorful stripe.

Common Recipe Questions

→ How do you achieve clean, layered colors?

Chill each jello layer completely before gently adding the next. Pouring slowly ensures clear separation between colors.

→ Can different jello flavors be used?

Yes, you can select flavors that match your theme or personal taste, just keep the contrasting colors for a striking effect.

→ What’s the best way to add whipped cream?

Spooning or piping whipped cream right before serving keeps it fluffy and prevents melting into the jello layers.

→ Are there alternatives to candy corn garnish?

Try using mini marshmallows, colored sprinkles, or small fruit pieces for a different decorative touch.

→ How far ahead can these be prepared?

Assemble the jello cups up to a day ahead and keep refrigerated. Add whipped cream and garnish just before serving.