Bookmark
This Jack-O-Lantern Orange Creamsicle Milkshake is pure Halloween fun in a glass and delivers the nostalgic combination of orange sherbet and vanilla with a creamy twist. Whether you are hosting a party or just want a festive treat at home, this milkshake has become a playful tradition for my nieces and nephews every October.
Every time I serve this at Halloween gatherings the glasses are empty in minutes and it always brings out big smiles from both kids and adults
Ingredients
- Orange sherbet: adds zingy citrus flavor and rich color choose a sherbet with real fruit for the brightest taste
- Vanilla ice cream: brings a smooth creaminess look for French vanilla if you love extra richness
- Milk: helps blend everything to the perfect sipping consistency use whole milk for maximum creaminess or your favorite milk alternative
- Whipped cream: for a playful and creamy topping go with homemade or your favorite store brand
- Orange sprinkles: finish the milkshake with a bit of sparkle seek out festive sprinkles for that special Halloween touch
Step by Step Instructions
- Combine Ingredients:
- Add orange sherbet vanilla ice cream and milk to a blender This order helps prevent sticking and blends faster
- Blend Until Smooth:
- Blend on medium speed working up to high for about sixty seconds Make sure everything looks creamy and there are no chunks If needed scrape down the sides and blend a bit longer for extra smoothness
- Pour and Decorate:
- Pour the milkshake into chilled glasses I love using clear glasses to really show off the color Top each with whipped cream piped in generous swirls and sprinkle a big pinch of orange sprinkles over each glass
- Serve Right Away:
- These milkshakes are best enjoyed immediately while they are cold and creamy If making for a group pour and decorate just before serving for the freshest taste
Bookmark
Orange sherbet is my favorite part because it tastes just like the popsicles my grandma used to bring us after trick or treating Each year my cousins and I would try to outdo each other with sprinkle shapes on top
Storage Tips
These milkshakes really shine fresh so blend only as much as you will drink at once If you have leftovers pour into popsicle molds and freeze for a tasty Halloween ice pop Treat
Ingredient Substitutions
No orange sherbet on hand Try using orange soda with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream for a quick fizz Take care though it will be bubblier
For dairy free You can use coconut milk ice cream or oat milk and choose an allergy friendly whipped topping
Serving Suggestions
Serve these with fun Halloween paper straws or dress up each glass with a little jack o lantern face sticker Pair with easy snacks like popcorn balls or pumpkin cookies for an easy party treat
Cultural and Historical Touch
The orange creamsicle dates back to summertime ice cream trucks in the United States but dressing it up for Halloween brings a new twist on a childhood favorite Making these shakes while carving pumpkins with my family has turned into our own holiday tradition
Bookmark
Common Recipe Questions
- → Can I use frozen yogurt instead of sherbet?
Yes, frozen yogurt offers a tangy twist and a lighter texture, blending well with the other ingredients.
- → How can I intensify the orange flavor?
Add a splash of orange juice or a bit of orange zest to heighten the citrus notes.
- → Is there a non-dairy option for this shake?
Substitute plant-based milk and ice cream for a dairy-free, creamy result with similar consistency.
- → What toppings pair well besides whipped cream?
Try orange sugar crystals, crushed cookies, or candy corn for extra color and texture.
- → Can I make this ahead of time?
It's best enjoyed fresh, but blend the base in advance and garnish with whipped cream before serving.